Guiding Principles:
Land Tenure in Development Cooperation

gtz_s.gif (1630 Byte)

Orientierungsrahmen:
Bodenrecht und Bodenordnung

Deutsche Gesellschaft
für Technische Zusammenarbeit
Abt. 45 / Div. 45

 

Ulrich Löffler, (1996):
Land Tenure Developments in Indonesia

3.3.4 Agrarian Structure

Uneven distribution of land is not a new phenomenon on Java. One could, for example, distinguish between three classes on West Java even in pre-colonial times:

  • A large class of landless farmers who frequently resided with landowning families.
  • Farmers who controlled land, often communal land.
  • Village officials who controlled private land, communal land and large areas of village-owned land as their payment for handling government matters.[FN 90]

The first statistical data, from the findings of a study conducted in 1905, show an uneven distribution of control over land in West Java. The results of this study, known as the "Declining Welfare Inquiry" of "Mindere Welvaart-Onderzoek", shows that a large proportion (51 %) of the rural households were landless. Two-thirds (67 %) of the landowners owned less than 0.7 ha, and 7 % of the households controlled more than 4.2 ha of land.[FN 91] Many rural households controlled dozens of hectares of land.[FN 92]

The results of the Agricultural Census [FN 93] conducted in 1963, 1973, 1983 and 1993 have continued to reflect the imbalance over control of land. According to the agrarian census of 1993, there are about 19.7 million land-holding farm households [FN 94] in Indonesia (from a total of about 42 million households). Of these, around 9.6 million land-holding farm households (or about 49 %) have less than 0.5 ha, and 14 million land-holding farm households (or about 71 %) have less than 1 ha of land (see also table 2).[FN 95]

Table 2: Number of Land Holding Farm Household by Size of Land Controlled and Farm Household Classification [FN 96]

Size of land controlled (ha)

Land holding farm household

Paddy / Secondary Crops

Horti-culture

Estates Crops

Livestock Breeding

Timber culture

Fresh water-pond / Paddy field culture

Brackish waterpond culture

< 0.05

646 372

225 303

57 492

21 346

385 168

7 805

37 066

634

0.05-0.09

948 296

751 041

146 691

81 939

209 843

17 067

30 456

844

0.10-0.14

1 218 949

1 084 817

204 328

159 557

239 683

29 070

34 485

1 007

0.15-0.19

1 200 783

1 104 986

206 268

175 708

228 131

26 807

29 941

1 421

0.20-0.24

1 150 639

1 065 280

213 918

196 942

233 720

35 055

32 202

1 947

0.25-0.49

4 417 121

4 118 584

956 699

972 618

1 024 410

180 017

126 634

10 047

0.50-0.74

2 934 875

2 675 579

746 344

908 341

760 234

149 894

83 072

12 069

0.75-0.99

1 438 870

1 321 266

423 497

540 765

411 037

89 056

50 533

7 868

1.00-1.24

1 644 860

1 383 989

476 335

766 876

433 581

82 173

44 184

12 004

1.25-1.49

662 624

607 832

212 852

303 349

200 260

40 761

21 932

4 799

1.50-1.99

1 004 734

871 343

332 312

565 289

300 244

60 913

31 306

9 186

2.00-2.99

1 457 561

1 223 692

496 113

826 165

416 991

63 038

34 975

16 392

3.00-3.99

506 675

397 058

170 907

365 336

147 468

22 113

14 170

8 418

4.00-4.99

211 339

172 039

77 161

151 650

66 915

10 177

5 701

5 775

5.00-7.49

188 881

148 732

68 274

144 824

60 227

9 139

5 961

7 349

7.50-9.99

43 319

34 191

15 210

33 418

14 501

2 328

1 659

2 404

> 10.00

37 846

28 010

13 211

30 199

14 009

2 354

2 224

2 539

Total

19 713 806

17 213742

4817 636

6244 343

5 146 447

827 767

576 505

104 703

 

On Java, the land holdings are even smaller on average. In 1993, for example, more than 40 % of the farms on West Java had an area less than 0.2 ha, and about 73 % of the farms had an area less than 0.5 ha Only 0.2 % of the farms on West Java have an area of more than 5 ha.[FN 97]

Apart from land holding size, interest has to be focused on land quality. Ten acres of high quality land, irrigated and suitable for rice crops can be large enough to support a farm family, while ten acres of rainfed land in a remote upland area might be insufficient for the livelihood of a cultivator’s family.[FN 98] But also on irrigated rice fields cropping intensity can vary enormously. Cropping intensity ranges from 64 percent (in Kalimantan) to 224 percent (in East Java).[FN 99]

On Java land is usually divided in home gardens (Pekarangan), wet rice fields (Sawah) and rain-fed fields (Tegalan). The irrigated areas are concentrated in Java (2,535,000 ha or 57,8 % of the total irrigated areas). [FN 100]

It is difficult to secure reliable land area figures for areas outside Java. But in general the land holding sizes seem in the outer islands to be larger than in Java. The land / person ratio in the Sanggau District in West Kalimantan, for example, was 4.14 ha / person in 1991. However, if population figures were related only to land not classified as forest land, the resulting land / person ratio was 1.93 ha / person. [FN 101]

The agrarian census form 1983 also indicated that 14 % of the total operated area in Indonesia is rented-in land. The amount of rented-in land (2,830,000 ha) exceeded by far the amount of land rented out (around 800,000 ha). There were several reasons given for this:[FN 102]

  • a considerable amount of operated land is not under individual title:
  • land is still considered as "communal" land (e.g. Bengkok on Java)
  • land formerly owned by non-household institutions (estates, Government)
  • certain people do not report land rented out for fear of being seen to contravene the provisions of the BAL.

Nearly half the rented-in land is in holdings under one hectare. On the other side only ca. 28 percent of the land rented-in is found in holdings over two hectares. Thus, it is difficult to support the claim that the existing land rented-in system leads to more land being transferred to the larger holdings. The reverse seems to be the case.[FN 103]

It becomes clear from the agrarian structure briefly sketched here, that agriculture could only provide a part of the livelihood of many rural households and that they have to increase their income by taking employment outside agriculture.